The UK's approach to attracting foreign entrepreneurs and investors has evolved significantly from the Entrepreneur Visa to the Innovator Visa and the recent Innovator Founder Visa. This transition reflects the UK's aim to attract innovative businesses and experienced entrepreneurs while ensuring the benefits to its economy and society. Here's a detailed look at the historical context and evolution of these visa categories from 2020 to 2023.

‍

Entrepreneur Visa to Innovator Visa

The UK Entrepreneur Visa was designed for individuals looking to establish, join, or take over one or more businesses in the UK. This visa category required applicants to have access to at least £200,000 in investment funds or £50,000 if the funds were from a reputable source, such as a venture capital firm, government department, or business incubator. However, in a move to streamline the process and focus more on innovation and scalability, the UK government replaced the Entrepreneur Visa with the Innovator Visa in March 2019.

‍

Innovator Visa Introduction and Requirements

The Innovator Visa was introduced with a clear focus on individuals with innovative, viable, and scalable business ideas. Unlike the Entrepreneur Visa, the Innovator Visa required applicants to have their business ideas assessed and endorsed by an approved endorsing body, demonstrating that the idea was new, needed in the market, and had growth potential. The investment threshold was also set at £50,000, lower than the Entrepreneur Visa, making it more accessible for budding entrepreneurs with impactful business ideas.

‍

Evolution of the Innovator Visa (2020-2023)

Since its introduction, the Innovator Visa has undergone several changes to make the UK more attractive to international talent and investment. The focus has remained on innovation, with the government refining the endorsement process to ensure that only genuinely innovative and viable business proposals receive approval. The visa provides a pathway to permanent residency and citizenship, subject to meeting certain conditions, such as the success of the business and its contribution to the UK economy.

‍

The criteria for endorsement have been periodically reviewed to keep pace with the dynamic nature of global business innovation. The endorsing bodies, which include business accelerators, seed competitions, and industry-specific experts, play a crucial role in the vetting process, ensuring that applicants have a solid business plan and the potential to contribute significantly to the UK's economy.

‍

Innovator Founder Visa

The Innovator Founder Visa 2023, introduced on April 13, 2023, streamlines the process for entrepreneurs aiming to start a business in the UK with their innovative ideas or significant contributions. It consolidates the previously separate innovator and start-up visa routes into a singular option for international business founders. Key highlights and improvements of this visa include:

‍

• Elimination of Investment Threshold: Unlike the previous £50,000 requirement under the innovator route, this visa does not specify a minimum investment amount. Applicants are instead required to present a business plan demonstrating the venture's sustainability without a predefined funding level.
• Flexibility in Employment: Visa recipients can engage in additional employment outside their business, provided the job matches or exceeds the skill level of RQF level 3 (equivalent to high school education).

Accelerated Path to Permanent Residence: The Innovator Founder Visa offers a faster route to obtaining 'indefinite leave to remain' in the UK. Holders can apply for permanent residency after just three years of continuous residence, compared to the five-year requirement of other categories, contingent upon meeting certain business performance and involvement criteria.

To provide a more comprehensive analysis incorporating additional numbers and statistics regarding the Innovator Visa application success rates and trends from 2020 to 2023, let's delve into the available data:

• 2020:

• In the year 2020, the Innovator Visa saw relatively low application numbers. The UK government reported that the number of applications was limited, reflecting the stringent criteria and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on international mobility and business planning.

• 2021:

• The year 2021 saw a slight improvement in application numbers as global travel restrictions began to ease. However, the success rate remained a challenge, with many applicants struggling to meet the high standards set by the endorsement bodies.

• 2022:

• In 2022, there was a modest increase in the number of applications and approvals, indicating a growing awareness of the visa route and possibly a better alignment between applicants' proposals and the expectations of endorsing bodies. Yet, the overall numbers remained low compared to other visa categories, underscoring the visa's niche target demographic and the challenges faced by applicants in meeting its requirements.

• 2023:

• Initial data for 2023 suggests a continuation of the trend observed in 2022, with a steady but slow increase in application numbers. In the year ending June 2023, the UK's Innovator visa saw a notable increase in activity. Specifically, the visa category experienced an 88% increase, with a total of 494 visas granted. This substantial increase reflects a growing interest and acceptance of the Innovator visa route among entrepreneurs looking to start their businesses in the UK.

UK Innovator Founder Visa and the UK Tech Sector

The Innovator Founder Visa has played a significant role in bolstering the UK's tech sector by attracting talented entrepreneurs with innovative ideas to contribute to the economy. The impact of the Innovator Founder Visa on the UK tech sector can be observed in several key areas:

‍

Attraction of Global Talent

The Innovator Founder Visa has been instrumental in attracting entrepreneurs from around the world to the UK tech sector. By offering a pathway for talented individuals to establish and grow their businesses in the UK, the visa has contributed to the diversification and enrichment of the tech ecosystem. The presence of international talent has fostered innovation, introduced new perspectives, and facilitated the exchange of knowledge and ideas within the sector.

‍

Growth and Development of Tech Startups

With the support of the Innovator Founder Visa, the UK has seen a significant increase in the number of tech startups. These startups have contributed to the sector's growth by introducing innovative products and services, driving technological advancements, and competing on a global scale. The visa ensures that these startups are not only innovative but also viable and scalable, emphasizing the importance of sustainable growth and long-term success.

‍

Job Creation and Economic Contributions

Entrepreneurs who move to the UK under the Innovator Visa contribute to the economy by creating jobs and investing in local communities. As these startups grow, they require a skilled workforce, thereby creating employment opportunities within the tech sector and related industries. This job creation is crucial for the overall health of the UK economy and helps maintain the tech sector's position as a leading global player.

‍

Sector Growth Analysis

The UK tech sector has continued to grow, retaining its position as the top tech hub in Europe and ranking third globally​​. The country has produced nearly 400 high-growth startups since 2000, including 144 unicorns and 237 futurecorns. This growth is supported by the UK's focus on innovation, safety, transparency, and fairness in regulation, as well as initiatives to upskill and reskill the workforce. The Innovator Founder Visa has played a part in this success by attracting and retaining entrepreneurial talent, contributing to the sector's resilience and growth.

‍

UK Innovator and Innovator Founder Visa Success Rates

‍

The overall success rate for Innovator and Innovator Founder visa applications remains substantial at 87.80% but saw a decline of 11% in 2022 relative to 2019 and a decrease of 8.6% from the year before.

‍

Innovator Visa Approval Rates:

• 2019: 93.30%
• 2020: 84.70%
• 2021: 90.90%
• 2022: 82.30%
• Average approval rate for the Innovator visa: 87.80%

‍

The application process for the Innovator Visa, specifically tailored for tech or IT entrepreneurs, involves a series of steps designed to assess the eligibility, innovation, and viability of the business proposal. Here’s a detailed overview of the process, eligibility criteria, financial requirements, and necessary documentation for prospective applicants.

‍

‍

Eligibility Criteria

‍

To qualify for the Innovator Visa, an applicant must satisfy the following conditions:

• Age: Must be at least 18 years old.
• English Proficiency: Demonstrate a B2 level of English proficiency on the CEFR scale by:

• Passing a Secure English Language Test (SELT) from an approved provider.
• Having a GCSE, A level, Scottish National Qualification level 4 or 5, Scottish Higher, or Advanced Higher in English, acquired through schooling in the UK initiated before the age of 18.
• Holding a degree taught in English. For degrees obtained abroad, equivalency through Ecctis must be confirmed.

• Education: Although not strictly required, having a Bachelor’s degree is recommended.
• Innovative Business Idea: Applicants must present a business idea that is original and viable, intending to be developed within the UK.
• Endorsement: A key requirement is obtaining an endorsement from an approved endorsing body.
• Financial Requirement: Applicants need to show they have at least £1,270 in savings held for 28 consecutive days prior to the application to support themselves in the UK.

‍

Developing a Business Plan

A comprehensive business plan is crucial for securing the necessary endorsement. It should detail:

• Innovation: How the business addresses a market gap or offers a unique competitive edge.
• Viability: Evidence of the entrepreneur's ability to establish and manage a successful business, including market knowledge, business acumen, and necessary funding.
• Scalability: The potential for growth and job creation, with a focus on both domestic and international markets.

‍

Obtaining the Endorsement

Endorsements must be secured from an approved body, such as Envestors Limited, UK Endorsing Services, Innovator International, or The Global Entrepreneurs Programme (GEP). These bodies evaluate the business idea’s market potential, the entrepreneur’s understanding of the market, and the growth prospects of the idea.

‍

Application Process

Upon securing an endorsement, the following documentation is required for the Innovator Visa application:

• A valid passport or other identification documents.
• Bank statements demonstrating the required financial savings.
• Proof of English language proficiency.
• Tuberculosis test results, if applicable.
• Any non-English or Welsh documents must be accompanied by certified translations.
• An endorsement letter from an approved endorsing body.

Applicants must also undergo an identity verification process, which can involve biometric data collection or using the ‘UK Immigration: ID Check’ app, depending on the applicant's nationality.

UK Innovator Founder Visa Requirements

To qualify for the Innovator Visa, an applicant must satisfy the following conditions:

• Age: Must be at least 18 years old.
• English Proficiency: Demonstrate a B2 level of English proficiency on the CEFR scale by:

• Passing a Secure English Language Test (SELT) from an approved provider.
• Having a GCSE, A level, Scottish National Qualification level 4 or 5, Scottish Higher, or Advanced Higher in English, acquired through schooling in the UK initiated before the age of 18.
• Holding a degree taught in English. For degrees obtained abroad, equivalency through Ecctis must be confirmed.

• Education: Although not strictly required, having a Bachelor’s degree is recommended.
• Innovative Business Idea: Applicants must present a business idea that is original and viable, intending to be developed within the UK.
• Endorsement: A key requirement is obtaining an endorsement from an approved endorsing body.
• Financial Requirement: Applicants need to show they have at least £1,270 in savings held for 28 consecutive days prior to the application to support themselves in the UK.

‍

Developing a Business Plan

A comprehensive business plan is crucial for securing the necessary endorsement. It should detail:

• Innovation: How the business addresses a market gap or offers a unique competitive edge.
• Viability: Evidence of the entrepreneur's ability to establish and manage a successful business, including market knowledge, business acumen, and necessary funding.
• Scalability: The potential for growth and job creation, with a focus on both domestic and international markets.

‍

Obtaining the Endorsement

Endorsements must be secured from an approved body.  The endorsing bodies authorized to issue endorsements for Innovator Founder Visas include:

• Envestors Limited
• UK Endorsing Services
• Innovator International
• The Global Entrepreneurs Programme (GEP)

In evaluating endorsement applications, endorsing bodies assess various factors, such as the need for your business in the UK, your understanding of the market, realistic goals, and potential for growth. Consequently, the endorsement ensures that only businesses with a promising chance of success progress to the subsequent phase.

If the endorsement application is successful, you will receive a letter of endorsement for processing your Innovator Founder visa application.

Application Process

In the application process for the Innovator Founder Visa, it is mandatory to include an Endorsement letter confirming that your business idea has been evaluated and endorsed by a recognized body.

‍

Moreover, you are required to furnish the following documents:

• A valid passport or another form of identification to prove your identity and nationality.
• Bank statements showing you have held a minimum balance of £1,270 in your account for 28 days in a row before applying;
• Certificates demonstrating your proficiency in the English language;
• Results of a Tuberculosis test, if required by the regulations of your home country;
• If your documents are not in English or Welsh, certified translations must be provided;
• Make sure your passport has an empty page for the visa stamp, especially if you're from a non-EU country or have an EU passport without a biometric chip;
• Depending on your specific situation, you may need to provide additional documents with your application.

‍

For identity verification during the application, the method varies according to your nationality and the type of passport you hold. You will either:

• Be required to visit a visa application center to have your fingerprints and photo taken for a biometric residence permit, or
• Utilize the ‘UK Immigration: ID Check’ app to scan your identity document and either create a new one or log into an existing UK Visas and Immigration (UKVI) account.

‍

You will receive detailed instructions on these procedures once you initiate your application. If you need to attend an appointment:

• Your passport and documents may be held by the center while your application is processed.
• It may be necessary to travel to the closest visa application center for your appointment, which might be in a different country.

‍

Challenges Faced by Applicants

‍

Endorsement Process

• Complexity and Subjectivity: The need for endorsement by an approved body adds a layer of complexity and subjectivity to the application process. Applicants report that criteria can seem opaque and decisions inconsistent​​.
• Limited Number of Endorsing Bodies: There's a limited pool of endorsing bodies, which can lead to bottlenecks and longer waiting times for applicants seeking endorsements​​.

‍

Investment Requirement

• Proof of Funds: Although there are no specific investment requirements for obtaining endorsement for your business idea, applicants still must provide evidence of their investment funds. It can be challenging, especially if the funds are sourced from multiple investors or are in different formats​​.

‍

Operational Constraints

• Renewal and Settlement Criteria: The criteria for visa renewal and eventual settlement (indefinite leave to remain) are rigorous, requiring proof of business success, job creation, and other milestones that may be difficult to achieve within the initial visa period​​.

‍

Criticisms of the Visa Process

• Lack of Transparency: Critics argue that the application process lacks transparency, particularly regarding how decisions are made by endorsing bodies and the criteria used by the Home Office for final visa approval​​.
• Inconsistency in Decision-Making: There is perceived inconsistency in decision-making, both at the endorsement stage and during the visa application review by the Home Office, leading to uncertainty and frustration among applicants​​.
• The barrier to Talent: The challenges and uncertainties associated with the Innovator Founder Visa are seen as barriers that prevent highly talented and innovative entrepreneurs from choosing the UK as a base for their startups, potentially impacting the UK's position as a leading startup hub​​​​.

Predictions and potential changes for the UK Innovator Founder Visa beyond 2023

1. Tighter Scrutiny and Enhanced Endorsement Criteria

Given the importance of ensuring that only viable, scalable, and innovative businesses are supported, the endorsement process might become more stringent. The government could introduce more specific criteria or guidelines for endorsing bodies to assess the potential impact and sustainability of proposed business ventures​​.

2. Adjustments to Investment Requirements

There could be adjustments to the investment requirements based on economic conditions and the needs of different sectors. The government may also consider different tiers of investment for various types of businesses, potentially offering more flexibility for startups in emerging sectors or technologies.

3. Broader Sector Focus

While the visa currently supports a wide range of sectors, future iterations might broaden or shift the focus to align with national strategic priorities, such as green technology, digital innovation, or healthcare solutions. This could involve the introduction of special endorsements for entrepreneurs in these priority sectors.

4. Enhanced Support and Integration Initiatives

The UK may introduce additional support mechanisms for Innovator Founder Visa holders to ensure their successful integration and contribution to the UK economy. This could include expanded networking opportunities, mentorship programs, and access to innovation hubs and research facilities.

5. Pathways to Settlement

The existing pathway to settlement (Indefinite Leave to Remain) for Innovator Founder Visa holders might be refined to better recognize the contributions of successful entrepreneurs. This could involve adjustments to the criteria for settlement, such as the recognition of non-financial contributions or the impact on the local community and economy​​.

6. Collaborations with Educational Institutions

To foster a stronger link between academic research and entrepreneurial innovation, the government might encourage or facilitate collaborations between visa holders and UK universities or research institutions. This could help in translating cutting-edge research into commercially viable ventures.

7. Digital and Technological Advancements

The application process itself may see further digitalization and the use of technology to streamline applications, making them more efficient and user-friendly. This could include AI-driven tools to pre-assess eligibility or automated updates on application status.

8. Global Competition and Partnerships

In response to global competition for talent, the UK might forge international partnerships or reciprocal agreements that facilitate the mobility of entrepreneurs and their ideas. This could help in maintaining the UK's position as a leading destination for innovation and entrepreneurship.

‍

These predictions are speculative and based on the current direction of the UK government's immigration and economic policies. Actual changes will depend on a range of factors including economic conditions, political priorities, and the evolving needs of the UK economy. Continual monitoring of official announcements and policy updates will be essential for those interested in the Innovator Founder Visa route.

‍